Eitiqad Magazine Publishing Ethics

Eitiqad Magazine Publishing Ethics
Share this post :

Publishing Ethics of Eitiqad Journal 

 

1. The Journal 's administration is committed to protecting the authors' intellectual property rights.

2. The Journal 's administration adheres to the principle of non-discrimination based on race or gender, basing the evaluation and analysis of ideas and topics on the standards of scientific thought and rigorous research methodologies.

3. The Journal 's administration maintains strict confidentiality throughout the peer-review process; the identities of reviewers are not disclosed to authors, nor are the identities of authors disclosed to reviewers, access to such information is restricted to the Editor-in-Chief and the editorial board.

4. The Journal is committed to respecting the intellectual property rights associated with translated research.

5. Research submissions must adhere to standards of academic integrity and the ethics of scientific research.

6. Research must not have been previously published in a Journal or book, nor derived from an academic thesis; furthermore, it must not be currently pending publishing or simultaneously submitted to another entity.

Using Artificial Intelligence Tools

The Journal regards artificial intelligence tools as aids for researchers within limited scopes, provided they do not compromise the originality of the research or replace the scholarly and intellectual effort undertaken by the author. Accordingly, the Journal adopts the following standards:

A. Acceptable Use Limits:

Authors are permitted to use artificial intelligence tools for supporting tasks that do not constitute the core of the scholarly contribution, such as proofreading, refining phrasing, suggesting linguistic alternatives, organizing or reordering ideas, and initial translation (provided the output is reviewed and verified for accuracy), as well as suggesting keywords or preliminary research avenues. In all these cases, it is required that the idea, argument, analysis, formulation of the problem, derivation of conclusions, and critical stance remain the author's own work.

B. Unacceptable Use

The Journal does not accept research papers, in which the scientific content, whether in whole or in substantial part, has been generated using artificial intelligence tools, even if the author has subsequently made linguistic or stylistic revisions. This applies to the use of such tools for drafting sections, constructing analyses and arguments, drawing conclusions, or formulating the scholarly discussions that constitute the core of the researcher's contribution. It is also prohibited to use artificial intelligence to generate text that implies it is the product of the researcher's own intellectual effort or critical analysis, when the intellectual content was actually produced by those tools.

C. Sources, References, and Citations

Artificial intelligence tools are not considered reliable scholarly sources for substantiating or documenting information. Researchers are responsible for consulting the original sources and independently verifying the accuracy of the information, texts, quotations, references, and page numbers cited in their research. The use of references or citations generated by such tools without directly verifying the existence of the source, the accuracy of its bibliographic information, and the correspondence of the citation to the material quoted is also prohibited. Fabricated or unverifiable citations constitute a breach of the principles of academic integrity, regardless of whether they result from the use of artificial intelligence tools or any other means.

D. Author's Responsibility

The author bears full scholarly and ethical responsibility for all parts of their research; the use of artificial intelligence tools does not, under any circumstances, absolve the author of this responsibility. This responsibility encompasses ensuring the accuracy of information, the correctness of citations and references, the originality of ideas and analyses, and the protection of intellectual property rights, as well as ensuring the research is free from plagiarism, fabrication, or falsification.

Furthermore, authorship may not be attributed to an artificial intelligence tool, nor may such a tool be listed among the authors, as it lacks the legal or ethical capacity to bear the responsibilities associated with scientific publishing.

E. Disclosure of Use

If the use of artificial intelligence goes beyond proofreading or minor stylistic improvements, the author must disclose the nature of such use and the specific tool employed, while identifying the sections where it was utilized in accordance with the Journal 's controls. Such disclosure does not imply acceptance of all forms of use; the research remains 
subject to the Journal 's standards regarding originality and intellectual independence.

F. The Journal 's Right to Verify

The Journal reserves the right to request clarifications from the author regarding the research methodology or the use of artificial intelligence tools therein, as well as to request whatever is necessary to verify the originality of the scholarly material or the accuracy of sources and references, should there be substantive grounds for doing so. It does not rely solely on the results of AI-generated text detection tools as conclusive evidence; rather, it treats these indicators as part of the editorial and scientific verification process, evaluating them based on the totality of available evidence.

I. Acknowledgment of Responsibility

Submitting research to the Journal constitutes an acknowledgment by the author that any use of artificial intelligence tools, if applicable, has adhered to the limits permitted by this policy, and that the core scientific and intellectual content is the product of their own work and effort.

The author bears sole and full responsibility for any violation resulting from the use of these tools, whether discovered during the review and editing stages or after publishing. The Journal reserves the right to take appropriate action in accordance with its editorial policies and publishing ethics, including rejecting the research, requesting revisions, or retracting it after publishing, should a significant violation be established.

 

 

 

Comments


Open Access Statement
This is an open-access journal which means that all content is freely available without charge to the user or his/her institution. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles, or use them for any other lawful purpose, without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author. This is in accordance with the BOAI definition of open access.
All articles published in this journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). Under this license, authors retain ownership of the copyright for their content, but allow anyone to download, reuse, reprint, modify, distribute, and/or copy the content as long as the original authors and source are cited.
messages.copyright © 2023,